Skip to main content

Sequence of returns: why the first years matter

By the Filoah team · Last checked November 21, 2026 · Rules as of the 2026 tax year

The short answer

Sequence of returns risk is the risk that markets fall early in retirement, while you are taking money out. A loss in the first years hurts more than the same loss later, because you sell more of your savings at low prices and have less left to grow when markets recover.

Same returns, different order

Here is a short made-up example. The numbers are simple so you can check them.

A person starts with $1,000,000. They take $50,000 at the start of each year. Over three years, the market has one bad year (down 20%) and two good years (up 10% each).

Bad year first (down 20%, then up 10%, then up 10%):

  • Year 1: $1,000,000 minus $50,000 is $950,000. Down 20%, it ends at $760,000.
  • Year 2: $760,000 minus $50,000 is $710,000. Up 10%, it ends at $781,000.
  • Year 3: $781,000 minus $50,000 is $731,000. Up 10%, it ends at $804,100.

Bad year last (up 10%, up 10%, then down 20%):

  • Year 1: $950,000, up 10%, ends at $1,045,000.
  • Year 2: $995,000, up 10%, ends at $1,094,500.
  • Year 3: $1,044,500, down 20%, ends at $835,600.

Same three returns. Same withdrawals. The bad-year-first order ends with $31,500 less.

Now take away the withdrawals. With nothing taken out, both orders end at $968,000. The order of returns does not matter when you only hold money. It matters when you are taking money out. That is why this risk is mostly about retirement.

What happened in real history

Filoah's stress test can run a plan through every past US market period since 1871, one starting in each year, in the order the years happened. This method is called Past markets.

We ran one setup: $1,000,000, $45,000 taken in year one (a 4.5% withdrawal rate), raised with inflation each year, for 30 years. The money was 75% in US stocks and 25% in US bonds, rebalanced each year, with no fees and no taxes.

It worked in 118 of 126 past periods. Look at two of them.

Start yearAverage yearly return, first 10 yearsAverage yearly return, all 30 yearsResult
1955about 8.9%about 3.6%Money lasted 30 years
1966about -1.5%about 4.3%Money ran out in year 23

These returns are for the 75/25 mix, after inflation, before any withdrawals.

Over the full 30 years, the 1966 retiree had the higher average return. But the 1955 retiree got the good years first. By the time weak years came, their savings had grown, and the same withdrawals were a smaller share of a bigger pot. The 1966 retiree got the weak years first. Prices also rose fast: from 1966, inflation averaged about 5.8% a year over the next 10 years. So spending, which rose with inflation, climbed while savings fell.

The failed start years were bunched together: 1906, each year from 1964 to 1969, and 1973. Bad starts tend to come in groups, because a bad decade is shared by everyone who retired just before it.

Quick check: will your savings last?

Runs in your browser. Nothing is saved.

Results are estimates, not promises. Past markets do not predict future ones.

Ways people think about this risk

These are ideas people weigh. Each one has a trade-off, and the stress test can show how each changes your own count.

  • Spend less to start. A lower first-year rate leaves more room for a bad start. The trade-off is less spending in the early years, which may be the years you most want to use it.
  • Change spending with the market. Some spending methods cut back after a fall and raise spending after a rise. The trade-off is spending that moves around from year to year. The stress test has many such methods to compare.
  • Hold some bonds or cash. A mix with bonds or cash can fall less in a crash. The trade-off is that it may grow less over a long time.
  • Wait for other income. Work a little longer, or have income that does not depend on markets, such as Social Security or a pension. The trade-off is what you give up to get it.

How to see it in your results

In the stress test, run Past markets and open the list of past periods. Each one shows its outcome, the first year spending fell short, if any, and the average US stock return and inflation over the period. That shows which start years were hardest for your plan, and what the markets did in them.

What this does not include

  • The made-up example is three years long, with withdrawals at the start of each year. Filoah's stress test pays each year's amount in 12 monthly steps.
  • The history results use no taxes and no fees. Both would lower the counts.
  • The quick test treats your savings as one account, with no 401(k), IRA or Roth rules and no required minimum distributions.
  • It adds no Medicare or health insurance costs, and no long-term care.
  • It uses US market history only, from 1871 to 2025.
  • It does not guess how long you will live. It runs for the years you pick.

Sources

Sources checked November 21, 2026.

Test your own numbers.

The free Retirement Stress Test runs your savings and spending through market history since 1871. No account needed.

This article is for learning. It is not tax, legal or investment advice.

Make my free plan

Google Analytics cookies count visits and stay off unless you say yes. See Privacy.